Model-based Control
The STorM32's model-based gimbal control can take into account, to a certain extend, the moments of inertia of the camera, and those of the roll and yaw arms.
For the underlying theory see Camera Gimbals: A Robotics Approach.
The camera is described by the three principal moments of inertia
- Ipitch, Iroll, Iyaw
The roll arm is modeled with these moments of inertia
- I2roll, I2yaw
and the yaw arm with
- I3yaw
Ideal Camera Design
From the perspective of PID control and axis coupling, the camera should ideally have these properties:
- Iroll ≈ Iyaw
- Ipitch ≈ Iroll, Iyaw or Ipitch << Iroll, Iyaw
The first condition is however more important than the second, and should be approached if possible.
A similar condition I2yaw ≈ I2pitch would ideally be also fulfilled for the roll arm, which is however unrealistic in practical builds.
Moments of Inertia
Estimates for the relative ratios of the moments of inertia of the camera can be obtained by approximating by a cuboid.
For a homogeneous, solid cuboid holds
I = 1/12 M ( a2 + b2 )
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moment_of_inertia
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_moments_of_inertia
Camera Panasonic
width | height | length |
---|---|---|
2.5 cm | 5.5 cm | 9 cm |
axis | approximate moment of inertia | relative ratio |
---|---|---|
pitch | I ∝ 2.52 + 5.52 = 36.5 | 1 |
roll | I ∝ 5.52 + 92 = 111.25 | 3.05 |
yaw | I ∝ 2.52 + 92 = 87.25 | 2.39 |
Camera GoPro Hero5
width | height | length |
---|---|---|
2.5 cm | 4.5 cm | 6.3 cm |
axis | approximate moment of inertia | relative ratio |
---|---|---|
pitch | I ∝ 2.52 + 4.52 = 26.5 | 1 |
roll | I ∝ 4.52 + 6.32 = 59.94 | 2.26 |
yaw | I ∝ 2.52 + 6.32 = 45.94 | 1.73 |
Camera Mobius
width | height | length |
---|---|---|
6 cm | 2 cm | 3 cm |
axis | approximate moment of inertia | relative ratio |
---|---|---|
pitch | I ∝ 62 + 22 = 40 | 1 |
roll | I ∝ 22 + 32 = 13 | 0.325 |
yaw | I ∝ 62 + 32 = 45 | 1.125 |
The Mobius camera style is not ideal, and thus more difficult to stabilize.